This holiday season, Emmanuel Ngene is spending his sixth year inside a
South Eastern United States penitentiary. At 56, he has 225 years, five
months and ten days left to serve for first degree rape of his daughter,
a crime he continues to deny, supported by members of his network of
friends and family. Few years after he was incarcerated, Emma Ngene had
partial stroke from the stress of the trial and subsequent imprisonment.
Emmanue Ngene, like most aspiring young Nigerians whose lives were
mortgaged to a battered inflation-driven economy of early 80s, sought
survival overseas. He chose the United States as his destination for
better life. He relocated in 1981. He would discover that life in God’s
own country was just an imaginary tale. On arrival, Emmanuel desired
education. But he had no money. Survival in a strange place, alone, was
then important to him. He engaged in menial jobs to support his dreams
of a better life here.
Years after he adapted to the lifestyle and surviving the culture shock
of a different environment, Emmanuel returned to his hometown in Eastern
Nigeria in search of a wife. He found love in Mary, a home girl. They
married months after. Emmanuel became a regular visitor to his
homeland from America; frequenting his village to be with his new wife
and family. He returned every holiday, especially Christmas, to
celebrate with his wife and other members of the family. Their first
child, a baby girl, was born on November 9, 1998 in Nigeria. The couple
would have two additional children after the birth of their daughter.
In June 2007, Emmanuel’s wife and children came to the United States to
live in a two-bedroomed apartment with their father. Family and friends
said that marital problems manifested when the wife was shocked at the
strange standard of living in America as compared to what she was used
to in Nigeria. She was also alleged to be disappointed that her husband
was a Taxicab driver, an unsteady source of financial income. Emmanuel
was gone all day, driving a taxi from morning and returned home at night
with not enough income to support the family. Soon, the parents began
arguing about money. Mary allegedly complained regularly of being bored
at home, caring for the children. Emmanuel, frustrated by her daily
musings about life in the United States and insufficient income,
encouraged his wife to get certification for CNA: Certified Nurses Aid:
she did, passed and got employed at one of the nursing homes as a care
giver: providing ageing American population with daily assisted living
and care. His wife’s new job, allegedly introduced her to a new social
environment. She immediately began to explore her new found friends and
friendship within her work place. Emmanuel suspected a change in his
wife’s attitudes: she was no longer the charming obedient wife he had
in Nigeria. She would refuse his sexual desires and appeals. The
marriage became tumultuous.
They were drifting apart as husband and wife: Emmanuel complained to his
friends that his wife was always gone and seemed no longer interested
in the marriage. It also affected his taxi cab business. He often
returned home midday to make sure the children were fed and cared for.
Most times, he alleged the wife was gone. When he asked her where she
had been, she yelled at him: ‘mind your business. I am a grown woman and
I can do whatever I want to do.’ Emma was raging inside. He thought he
had a decent beautiful wife that loved the family and the children. He
thought it was until death do them part! A wife he married and suffered
to bring to America. Their children were drifting apart too.
The circumstances that led Emmanuel Ngene into a lifetime jail are too
complex. The stories are bizarre from both sides. Ngene’s family
sources, almost seven years after he was found guilty, still believed he
was railroaded by his wife and the judiciary. Their stories remain
consistent, each alleging that Ngene’s wife, Mary, may have coerced her
daughter to lie that her father raped and assaulted her. Part of the
family version said that during one of Ngene’s lunch visits home to
check on the children, he allegedly found his then young daughter in an
explicit compromising position with a neighborhood boy, in the family’s
living room!. He became agitated, asked the boy to leave immediately.
Soon after the boy left, he grabbed his daughter and spanked her
intensely. Mother allegedly walked in as dad was spanking their
daughter. She jumped on him and began to scratch and scream. Their
daughter, disengaged from the whip, cried profusely from the burns of
the belt whipping. She had lacerations on her butt. Their mother, while
restraining Emmanuel, instructed their daughter to dial 911. Few minutes
later, police came to their door, handcuffed Emmanuel and took him down
town. The police officer, noticing the lacerations on the girl’s body,
requested for the ambulance to take the young girl and her mother to
hospital for medical observations and interrogation. Emmanuel was hauled
to jail!
However, in a court document filed, the court posited, “One day in
August 2007, defendant asked Cindy(to protect the minor child, the court
identified her as Cindy, not her real name) to help him check his email
on the computer in his bedroom. After they had finished with the email,
defendant told Cindy to stay in the room while he went into the
bathroom. He came out wearing only his underwear and a T-shirt. He asked
her if she knew what sex was and then pulled down her pants while she
was lying on the bed. He pulled off his underwear, got on top of her,
and had vaginal intercourse with her. On 31 August 2008, Cindy’s mother
took Cindy to the emergency room at Wake Med where they met with a
nurse, Kimberly Lewis, and a doctor, Dr. Chris Johnson. Ms. Lewis did a
head-to-toe assessment of Cindy and observed bruises on her arms. Cindy
told her the bruises came from a broomstick. Cindy also informed Ms.
Lewis that she had been sexually assaulted many times.
“Dr. Johnson took a basic history and examined Cindy to determine if she
needed immediate treatment. Cindy told him that defendant had been
having vaginal and anal intercourse with her over the past year. Because
she had not been assaulted within the past 72 hours, Dr. Johnson did
not perform a rape kit. Dr. Johnson’s examination of Cindy was limited
to her external genitalia and looking for signs of trauma, of which he
saw none. He diagnosed Cindy with alleged sexual abuse. He noticed that
Cindy appeared somewhat shy and that her mother was “appropriately
concerned and worried.”
The hospital notified Wake County Human Services (“WCHS”) and the
Raleigh Police Department (“RPD”) of the allegations. Katie Treadway of
WCHS and Officer Harvey of RPD arrived at the hospital to interview
Cindy. After describing the sexual conduct, Cindy also informed them
that one time she bled after defendant had sex with her. She also stated
that sometimes defendant “peed on her,” and she had to go in the
bathroom to clean herself up. Ms. Treadway felt Cindy was very detailed
in her description of the events.
Over the course of Cindy’s fourth grade school year, defendant engaged
in vaginal intercourse with Cindy approximately 10 times. Approximately
three of these times, defendant had her turn over on her stomach so he
could also penetrate her anus. In August 2008, Cindy finally disclosed
to her mother what defendant was doing.
At the hospital, the doctors during examination found that she had been
penetrated. The police officer asked her who may have penetrated her;
she looked at her mother, seeking protection. Her mother instructed her
to answer that it was her father! She reluctantly told the officer that
her father had penetrated her! The officer asked if she was sure, she
bowed and fearfully said yes sir!”
However, Emmanuel Ngene denied the rape charges and penetration of his
daughter. He contended that her daughter was sexually molested and
penetrated by a boy at her school in Nigeria, the head mistress of the
daughter’s school called him when the incident happened and he travelled
home to remove his daughter from the school because of the molestation.
The court wrote thus:
“Defendant first contends that the trial court erred in not allowing him
to testify regarding his claim that Cindy had been sexually assaulted
in 2006 by someone else while in Nigeria. He argues that this evidence
was admissible under N.C.R. Evid. 412(b) because it provided an
alternative explanation for the paediatrician’s physical findings.
Although Rule 412 generally excludes evidence of a complainant’s prior
sexual behaviour as irrelevant, it provides an exception for “evidence
of specific instances of sexual behaviour offered for the purpose of
showing that the act or acts charged were not committed by the
defendant.” N.C.R. Evid. 412(b)(2).
“Here, defendant testified during voir dire that, in 2006, he received a
call from his wife that Cindy had been sexually assaulted at school,
was walking funny, and was bleeding. He claimed that he flew home to
Nigeria and transferred Cindy from Graceland Private School, where the
assault had supposedly occurred, to another school.
“When Cindy and her mother were questioned on voir dire, however, each
denied that any sexual assault had occurred. Cindy acknowledged changing
schools, but her mother explained that she had moved Cindy to a
different school because Graceland Private School was too expensive.”
Emmanuel remained in the county jail as prosecutors began to build a
case against him. The prosecutor offered him a deal: Plead guilty and
spend 15 years in jail or go to trial and if found guilty, could face
250 years to life. He refused the deal and sought to be tried because it
was an abomination, in his culture, for a man to sexually molest his
own daughter and penetrate her. He felt his innocence and said that he
would rather die in jail than plead guilty to a crime he did not commit.
It took one year for Emmanuel to go to trial. It only took the jury
three hours to return with a guilty verdict. Emmanuel was sentenced to
300 to 369 years in prison. On December 3, 2009, Emmanuel Ngene began
serving his sentence. He was preparing to travel to Nigeria to bury his
mother when he was arrested.
“On 22 September 2008, a grand jury returned 15 separate bills of
indictment, charging defendant with four counts of indecent liberties
with a child, four counts of incest, three counts of first degree sexual
offence, and four counts of first degree rape. Following trial, the
jury found defendant guilty of all 15 counts and also found the
existence of an aggravating factor: that defendant had taken “advantage
of a position of trust or confidence to commit the offence or offences.”
The trial court entered 15 separate judgements. The court sentenced
defendant to four consecutive aggravated-range sentences of 300 to 369
months imprisonment for the four counts of first degree rape; three
consecutive aggravated-range sentences of 300 to 369 months imprisonment
for the three counts of first degree sex offence; four consecutive
presumptive-range sentences of 16 to 20 months imprisonment for the four
counts of incest; and four consecutive presumptive-range sentences of
16 to 20 months for the four counts of indecent liberties with a child.
Defendant timely appealed to this Court.”
I recently contacted Ms. Mary Ngene for interview with regards to this
essay. Her response:” If you write anything about me, I will sue you!”
No comments:
Post a Comment